Allen Edmonds vs Bruno Magli: Which Is Better?

There are a lot of different factors to consider when it comes time to buy a new pair of shoes.

Do you want something that will be comfortable for all-day wear, or do you need a dressier option for a special occasion?

Allen Edmonds and Bruno Magli are two brands that come to mind when thinking about high-quality shoes, but which one is the best choice for you?

The major difference between Allen Edmonds and Bruno Magli is that Allen Edmonds features a classic design, while Bruno Magli shoes come in more modern and trendy styles.

This is not to say that Bruno Magli shoes have a bad and non-acceptable design, this is just to show that when Allen Edmonds and Bruno Magli shoes are compared, the better styles lie in the Allen Edmonds shoes.

First glance

Allen Edmonds vs Bruno Magli

The first glance at a set of shoes should give you an insight into the shoes, you should be able to know if they are a good choice for you, taking into consideration their general look, feel, and style of the shoe.

This gives you the first impression of the shoe which matters a lot.

Let’s see what the first glance at  Allen Edmonds and Bruno Magli tell us.

Allen Edmonds

Allen Edmonds vs Bruno Magli

  • High-quality leather
  • Very expensive
  • Leather lining
  • Padded insole
  • Rubber sole

My first impression of Allen Edmonds shoes was that they were high-quality shoes. The shoes are made from high quality materials and the shoes are very well made. The shoes also look very stylish.

The shoes were comfortable and felt good on my feet. I thought the shoes looked good for business casual wear. I liked the way the shoes looked but I felt the shoes were too expensive.

I don’t think I would buy Allen Edmonds shoes because they are too expensive. I would recommend Allen Edmonds shoes to someone who is willing to spend a lot of money on shoes.

I think Allen Edmonds shoes would look good with a suit and would be appropriate for business casual wear.

the level of craftsmanship that went into making the shoes is one of its major perks. The materials used consisted of high-quality leather and a leather lining.

The leather lining also had jacquard linings that made the shoe breathable. There was a padded insole, and the sole itself was made of a rubber that had great traction. In addition, the leather was made in America.

What did impress me is how nice the shoes were, the quality of the leather, the craftsmanship, and the attention to detail.

Bruno Magli

Allen Edmonds vs Bruno Magli

  • Superb fit
  • High-end luxury shoes
  • Zip fasteners  with turnbuckles
  • Cool designs
  • Very expensive

Bruno Magli’s shoes are so comfortable. When you first put them on, they fit like a glove and your feet are so happy.

You can walk around the house for hours in them without getting tired. They even have super-cool designs.

Bruno Magli shoes are shoes of excellent quality. They have a rich heritage that dates back to 1954. They are high-end luxury shoes that are a symbol of style and quality.

There are two main branches of Bruno Magli shoes from which buyers can choose: the first is formal shoes that include dress shoes, Oxford shoes, and double monk shoes. The second is the casual line, which includes boat shoes, loafers, and slippers.

The first impression of Bruno Magli shoes is that they are synonymous with elegance, style, and luxury and can be seen as a symbol of good taste in Europe and the USA.

They are known for the quality and comfort of their shoes. These shoes are made from the finest materials and crafted to the utmost detail.

Some Bruno Magli shoes are offered with zip fasteners with turnbuckles, which make it easier to put on and remove the footwear.

Many people who have bought Bruno Magli shoes claim that the company’s products are the most comfortable shoes they have ever worn. The shoes are stylish and sophisticated.

Allen Edmonds vs Bruno Magli: Let’s Compare

Features Allen Edmonds Bruno Magli
Leather The hides used in the Allen Edmonds shoes come from animals like Cattle, pigs, Deer They are made with a type of leather that is very soft and smooth. This type of leather is called calfskin.
Sole Allen Edmonds shoes are made with the “commando” sole and it was designed for use by the military. It is very sturdy and provides good traction. Bruno Magli shoes. It is made from high-quality leather and provides a lot of durability and comfort.
Durability They are made with great quality and can last up to 3 years Bruno Magli shoes are not as durable as Allen Edmonds as they only last for 2 years
Price They are very expensive as their prices start from $260 to up to $1000 Its price is also similar to that of Allen Edmonds. Between $200 – $1000
Insoles The insoles are made of a dense high quality custom cork insole The insoles are padded leather insoles
Sizing/fit The shoes are very comfortable and conform well to the feet. Different brands of Bruno Magli fit differently.
Fashion quality They are very fashionable Bruno Magli is conservative and doesn’t look as fashionable as Allen Edmonds.
Footbed They are using fabric from a company called Tencel. Leather footbed which is not as breathable as the footbed of Allen Edmonds
Toe protection None Square toed


Allen Edmonds shoes are made of high-quality leather. The company uses a number of different types of leather, depending on the style and function of the shoe.

For example, calfskin is used for dress shoes, as it is soft and flexible. Nubuck is a type of suede that is made from the outer layer of a cow’s hide.

It is durable and water-resistant, making it a good choice for shoes that will be worn in wet environments.

While Bruno Magli shoes are a popular Italian brand that is known for their high quality and luxurious look.

The company uses a variety of different types of leather in the construction of their shoes, but the most common is calfskin.  is a type of leather that is made from the skin of a calf, and it is generally used to make high-end shoes and accessories.

When compared to each other, Allen Edmonds uses a more high-quality leather than Bruno Magli shoes


Allen Edmonds uses a Goodyear Welt construction process to create their shoes. This means that a single piece of leather is used to create both the upper and the sole of the shoe.

The upper is stitched to the welt, which is then attached to the sole. This creates a very sturdy shoe that can be resoled many times. The sole used is the commando sole.

Bruno Magli is handmade with the finest materials and attention to detail. The shoes are made with a type of sole called a Blake construction.

This is a Goodyear welted construction, which means that the sole is heat-sealed to the upper. This makes the shoes more durable and allows them to be resoled.

While the process of application of the sole of these two shoes is similar, Allen Edmonds shoes are much better than Bruno Magli shoes as they provide more traction and support.


The overall makeup and composition of Allen Edmonds make them much more durable than Bruno Magli.

Bruno Magli shoes are also durable but when in comparison to Allen Edmonds, they don’t stand a chance.


The two shoes are both very expensive. But then, Allen Edmonds cost more between $260-$1000. Meanwhile, Bruno Magli starts from $200.


Allen Edmonds shoes use CustomCork for their insoles. The custom cork insoles have a good fit and support your fit for a good and comfortable experience.

Bruno Magli shoes use a padded leather insole which gives the shoes a sturdy, impenetrable look.

In terms of strength of the insole, Bruno Magli has an edge. But according to comfortability, Allen Edmonds soles are more comfortable.

So your choice depends on sturdiness and comfortability.


Allen Edmonds shoes have a universal fit. Every shoe of theirs is made with every foot in mind. They are also true to size.

While Bruno Magli shoes have different sizes on a different sets of shoes. Some may be tighter, or too wide.

It is recommended to order half a size up when buying Bruno Magli shoes. This gives Allen Edmonds an edge over them in matters of fit.

Fashion quality

For Allen Edmonds, The quality of the shoe uppers is unmatched. The leather the shoe is made from is of high quality.

The leather sole is flexible. It can handle the ball impact. The leather sole is replaceable. The leather sole is resistant to water and stain.

The sole is replaceable so if you wear it out you don’t have to throw away the whole shoe. It’s easy to replace. 

For Bruno Magli, the shoe is made with a removable insole. The shoe laces are of good quality and it makes the shoe look good as well.

The shoe sole is made with high-quality rubber. The rubber sole can handle the ball impact. The rubber sole is replaceable. The rubber sole is resistant to water and stain.

They are both made with quality materials. But Allen Edmonds has a more fashionable look. Bruno Magli shoes have a more professional look.

Overall Verdict

Overall, you must note that Allen Edmonds are much better footwear than Bruno Magli shoes.

This is because Allen Edmonds are much more comfortable, they last longer, they are more fashionable and they offer more support.

The fact that Allen Edmonds shoes are better shouldn’t shield you from the fact that Bruno Magli also makes good footwear which is also good for you.

But then, compared to Allen Edmonds, Bruno Magli doesn’t stand a chance.

Why you should buy Allen Edmonds shoes

Allen Edmonds shoes are known as some of the best shoes in the world. They are very well made, have a great fit, and are going to last you for years.

If you have never owned a pair of Allen Edmonds shoes, you should definitely consider trying them out.

You will not regret the decision, and you will be very impressed by the quality of their shoes.. you should buy Allen Edmonds shoes because when you buy Allen Edmonds shoes, you are buying a pair of shoes that will last you for a very long time.

They are going to be very comfortable, and you will be able to wear them for a long time every single day.

If you are looking for a pair of shoes that are going to be comfortable for you, you will definitely want to give Allen Edmonds shoes a try.

The great thing about Allen Edmonds shoes is that they make shoes for men, women, and children.

Their shoes are not just for adults, but they have shoes for the whole family. You will be able to find the right shoes for everyone in your family.

You can purchase some Allen Edmonds shoes through these links below

Why you should buy Bruno Magli shoes

One of the most reputable shoe brands in the world is Bruno Magli shoes. The brand is known for its superior craftsmanship, luxury, and comfort.

They are designed with high quality and experience in mind, which makes them become the first choice for many people.

If you are a fashion lover or you are looking for a pair of beautiful and comfortable shoes, then you should know that Bruno Magli is always the best choice for you.

If you need to go to a party, you can wear a pair of black Bruno Magli shoes to get a good look. They are also great if you want to do some shopping in your local supermarket.

You can purchase some Bruno Magli shoes through the links below


This page may contain affiliate links.

To support the content and the knowledge I share here, I earn from qualifying purchases from Amazon at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Comment