The Allen Edmonds brand is known to be one of the biggest manufacturers of premium men’s footwear and accessories.
By adopting innovative manufacturing techniques, the brand has been able to make shoes that are not only fashionable but also comfortable and very durable.
The brand, since 1922, has relentlessly manufactured timeless and custom-made men’s shoes using only premium leather.
The quality of Allen Edmonds shoes is undoubted, and as you know, with high quality comes a high price.
It is not surprising that some people find Allen Edmonds shoes to be quite expensive and thus, are looking for an alternative that has the same or better quality but at a low price.
Whether the reason you are looking for an Allen Edmond alternative is because of the price or personal preference, this list will surely provide you with the best options out there. Let us get on to it!
| Allen Edmonds Alternatives | Features |
| Johnston and Murphy Men’s Conard Cap Toe | Alternative to Allen Edmonds Park Avenue Cap-Toe Oxford shoes |
| Cole Haan Men’s Original Shoes | Alternative to the Allen Edmonds Park Avenue Oxford Sneaker |
| Clarks Men’s Raharto Plain Oxford | Alternative to Edmonds Carlyle Plain-Toe Oxford shoe |
| Dream Pairs Bruno Marc | Alternative to Allen Edmonds Strand Cap-Toe Oxford shoe |
| Allonsi Men’s Wingtip Oxford Shoe | Alternative to Allen Edmonds McAlister Wingtip Oxford Shoe |
| Jousen Men’s Dress Shoes | Alternative to Allen Edmonds Strandmok Cap-Toe Oxford Shoe |
| Cole Haan Grand Crosscourt Sneakers | Alternative to Allen Edmonds Randolph Penny Loafers |
| Rockport Classic Penny Loafer | Alternative to Allen Edmond Burke Venetian Slip-on Sneaker |
| Cole Haan Tucker Venetian Slip-On Loafer | Alternative to Allen Edmond Burke Venetian Slip-on Sneaker |
| Stacy Adams Dickinson Cap-Toe Oxford Shoe | Alternative to Strand Cap-Toe Oxford |
| Cole Haan Original WingTip Oxford Shoes | Alternative for the Allen Edmonds Strand Suede Oxford Sneaker |
| Florsheim WingTip Oxford Sneakers | Alternative to Allen Edmonds Strand Oxford Sneakers |
| Bruno Marc Leather Oxford Dress Shoes | Alternative to Allen Edmonds Carlyle Plain-Toe Oxford Shoe |
| Rockport Classic Chukka Boot | Alternative to Allen Edmonds Discovery Chukka Boot |
| Wolverine 1000 Mile Fashion Boot | Alternative to Allen Edmond Burke Venetian Slip-on Sneaker |
| Bruno Marc Urban Suede Oxford Shoes | Alternative to Allen Edmonds Suede Oxford Shoe |
| Johnston & Murphy Venetian Shoe | Alternative to Allen Edmonds Venetian Moccasin |
| Deer Stags Chelsea Boot | Alternative to Allen Edmonds Chelsea Boot |
| Clarks Whiddon Cap Oxford Shoe | Alternative to Allen Edmonds Park Avenue Cap-Toe Oxford shoes |
| Temeshu Oxford Shoes | Alternative to Allen Edmonds McAlister Wingtip Oxford Shoe |
Johnston & Murphy Men’s Conard Cap Toe
If you are looking for a shoe that looks just exactly like an Allen Edmond, then this is it. This shoe is the exact alternative to the Allen Edmonds Park Avenue Cap-Toe Oxford shoes.
It comes with a classic cap toe design that uses intricate perforated detail to establish a stylish and creative pattern. Just like all Allen Edmonds products, this shoe is also primarily made of leather.
This is a great alternative to Allen Edmonds because it also makes you look classy, and can be styled on formal attire or on denim jeans.
This shoe is fitted with a cushioned insole that provides strong support to your feet as you wear them. So, if comfort is your thing, this shoe will treat your feet, no matter the shape, better than its Allen Edmonds counterpart.
Cole Haan Men’s Original Shoes
It has been determined that a lot of people love Allen Edmonds, however, they are put off by the amount they have to pay to acquire one so they seek alternatives.
This shoe right here is the perfect alternative to the Allen Edmonds Park Avenue Oxford Sneaker.
Both shoes are similar in physical outlook but the Cole Haan’s original shoe is one that combines beautiful design with superior comfort and yet comes at a reasonably affordable price.
This shoe has a leather and nubuck upper that is just the same as its Allen Edmonds counterpart. It is fitted with grand O.S comfort technology and comes with an EVA midsole and a rubber outsole, all of which contribute to making this shoe more comfortable than Allen Edmonds.
It uses a lace-up design for its closure which means you can easily adjust the tightness of the shoe.
This shoe offers every benefit you will get from the Allen Edmonds Park Avenue Oxford Sneaker, but it does so at a fantastic price.
Clarks Men’s Raharto Plain Oxford
One of the downsides of the Allen Edmonds Carlyle Plain-Toe Oxford shoe is how it is 100% formal.
However, this oxford shoe from Clarks is a perfect hybrid between a casual shoe and a formal shoe.
Fitted in this shoe is a removable ortholite footbed that comes with a soft cushioning technology that guarantees comfort with every step you take.
It ensures that you get maximum comfort whether you are at work or out during the weekend.
The major advantage this shoe has over its Allen Edmonds counterpart is the weight. This shoe is lightweight which makes it easier to wear and more comfortable on your feet than the Allen Edmonds.
Of all the shoes on this list, this is one of those that weigh less the most.
Dream Pairs Bruno Marc
This is another great shoe that I can vouch for to take the place of Allen Edmonds on your shoe rack.
It is as well made with 100% leather and possesses ornamental perforated patterns like its Allen Edmonds counterpart – the Allen Edmonds Strand Cap-Toe Oxford Shoe
The Allen Edmonds brand is known to make shoes that last very long, and that can be attributed to them using leather and rubber to make their soles.
However, the Dream Pairs brand has taken durability a notch higher by making the sole of this particular shoe out of hardwood.
This feature means that this shoe can last just as long as the Allen Edmonds Strand Cap-Toe Oxford Shoe
This shoe is fitted with a latex cushioned footbed and has its lining done using premium faux leather. The height of the heel is approximately 1” while the whole shoe weighs 2.45 pounds.
Allonsi Men’s Wingtip Oxford Shoes
This could well be the best shoe on this list. Crafted in full grain genuine leather, this shoe embodies everything about Allen Edmonds.
It was made from the finest hand-selected cow leather and crafted dyed and burnished by hand.
This is the exact same way Allen Edmonds manufactures their shoes. This shoe is the exact alternative to the Allen Edmonds McAlister Wingtip Oxford.
This shoe goes further to add a breathable sheep leather lining that helps to wick moisture away and keep your feet cool and fresh.
This is a feature that the Allen Edmonds McAlister Wingtip Oxford shoe does not have. In addition, this shoe is fitted with an EVA insole that provides you with incredible softness, flexibility, and comfort that lasts the entire day.
One of the selling points of Allen Edmonds is the class, but if you take one look at this shoe from the Allonsi brand you can see the elegance oozing out of it. This is the shoe to wear when you want to look your corporate best.
Jousen Men’s Dress Shoes
The next best Allen Edmonds alternative is this classic dress shoe from Jousen. This is one shoe you would love for its rich polishing, good gloss, and smooth touch.
This Oxford shoe is a great alternative to the Allen Edmonds Strandmok Cap-Toe Oxford Shoe because it can as well be worn to work or weddings or even prom.
The sole of the shoe is made of rubber and it comes in an exquisite design pattern that is not just beautiful but also non-slip. This is a shoe that not only makes you look dapper but also protects you from slipping on wet or smooth surfaces.
This shoe is fitted with a soft footbed that cushions your feet and also makes you comfortable. It as well comes with several layers of the material fitted in its bottom so it can stabilize the sole of your feet.
Cole Haan Grand Crosscourt Sneakers
Allen Edmonds does not make dress shoes alone, in fact, the Allen Edmonds Courtside Sneaker is one of the most popular and best-selling products of the brand.
This product from Cole Haan is the best alternative there is to the Allen Edmonds sneakers.
These sneakers are covered with sleek black leather and offer lightweight cushioned comfort. Just like its Allen Edmonds counterpart, it is very versatile and can be styled in any way you want it.
Price is another reason to consider this shoe over the Allen Edmonds because while the Allen Edmonds Courtside Sneakers cost close to $300, this product from Cole Haan can be gotten for less than $200.
Asides from the price, these sneakers from Cole Haan weighs super less than its Allen Edmond alternative.
Getting this product means you are getting everything the Allen Edmonds Courtside Sneakers has to offer for a much lesser price and a much lesser weight.
Rockport Classic Penny Loafer
A man’s shoe collection is not complete without a loafer. Loafer shoes are loved by men because of how easy and fast it is to slip them on, not forgetting they are multipurpose too.
Instead of getting the Allen Edmonds Randolph Penny Loafers, a more affordable and more comfortable alternative would be the Rockport Classic Penny Loafer.
This shoe is a polished and refined loafer from Rockport that was designed to be comfortable and stylish. Just like its Allen Edmonds counterpart, the upper of this shoe is made with smooth and easy-to-clean genuine leather.
The sponge EVA insole and the polyurethane outsole make this shoe absorb more shock and provide more comfort than the Allen Edmonds loafers.
This loafer feels so good on your feet that you would not believe that it is a dress shoe. This is the shoe that you can wear to a business meeting, in a suit, and to dinner with friends.
Cole Haan Tucker Venetian Slip-On Loafer
I know a friend who loved the way the Allen Edmonds Burke Venetian Slip-On Sneaker looked but he could not get it due to the price tag.
We started searching for shoes that looked almost or exactly the same, offer the same benefits but cost way lesser, and we stumbled on the Tucker Venetian Slip-On Loafer.
This loafer from Cole Haan has a sport-inspired design, and like its Allen Edmonds counterpart, it also comes with a sophisticated leather upper.
The only difference is that the Allen Edmonds Burke Venetian Slip-On Sneaker comes with a removable insole that helps to accommodate wider feet but this loafer from Cole Haan does not.
Asides from that, both shoes are very similar and perfect alternatives for each other.
Stacy Adams Dickinson Cap-Toe Oxford Shoe
The Allen Edmonds Strand Cap-Toe Oxford shoe is loved for its lace-up closure design, perforated brogue styling, and premium calfskin leather upper.
However, there is another shoe that has all the qualities mentioned above and more, the name of that shoe is the Stacy Adams Dickinson Cap-Toe Oxford Shoe.
This shoe is so much better than its Allen Edmonds counterpart in terms of comfort because it is fitted with a fully cushioned memory foam insole that provides superior comfort and better shock absorption.
In addition, the shoe also comes with breathable linings and lightweight construction that aids its durability.
Similar to the handcrafting done on all Allen Edmonds shoes, the Stacy Adams brand also spends time to hand burnish all its shoes, which includes this Dickinson Oxford shoe.
Cole Haan Original WingTip Oxford Shoes
Another shoe that will comfortably give any Allen Edmonds shoe a run for its money is this WingTip shoe from Cole Haan.
The Cole Haan brand combined the comfort of a sneaker, the detailed design of a brogue, and finally the sophistication of a lace-up closure design to make this shoe.
This shoe is the perfect alternative to the Allen Edmond Suede Oxford Sneaker. The Allen Edmonds and Cole Haans Product are similar in that, they both possess a premium suede upper.
In addition, both shoes are fitted with insoles that provide intense support and superb cushioning. Both shoes can be dressed casually and are perfect anyhow you choose to wear.
The advantage of the Cole Haan WingTip Oxford Shoe is that you get every quality in the Allen Edmonds counterpart at a lesser price. To be sincere, this shoe from Cole Haan is more versatile and be styled in more ways than the Allen Edmonds.
Florsheim WingTip Oxford Sneaker
Just as Allen Edmonds has its own Strand Oxford Sneakers, the Florsheim brand as well has its WingTip Oxford Sneaker.
Both shoes are amazingly similar with colors just being the main difference. Both shoes also feature a removable insole that offers superb support and cushioning to your feet.
The outsole of this Florsheim Oxford Sneaker offers incredible grip and stability that helps you navigate all types of floor surfaces.
This product from Florsheim is a direct alternative to the Allen Edmonds Strand Oxford Sneakers. In one look, you can see how similar both shoes are.
If you are unable to afford the Allen Edmonds, do not worry, Florsheim has the exact same product for a much lesser price.
Bruno Marc Leather Oxford Dress Shoe
This shoe from Bruno Marc is a show-off of a debonair flair. It features a classic plain-toe design and comes with a smooth and soft leather upper which makes this shoe a quality one to wear.
This oxford dress shoe has a breathable leather lining that ensures a comfortable experience for your feet.
This shoe is a great alternative and perfect replacement for the Allen Edmonds Carlyle Plain-Toe Oxford Shoes because they both share similar designs and features. Common to both shoes is a lace-up closure design that makes you look classic and also helps you get a snug fit.
While the Allen Edmonds features a custom cork insole that gives you a custom fit, the Bruno Marc shoe comes with a light padded latex footbed that ensures you get long-lasting comfort.
Rockport Classic Chukka Boot
This boot from Rockport is a shoe that adds a little attitude twist to your business attire. It is a shoe made with 100% leather and comes with a rubber sole.
You will love this boot for its versatile style that can get you through the day and well into the evening.
This shoe is a direct alternative to the Allen Edmonds Discovery Chukka Boot. Both boots are similar in their design, features, and even functions.
They are both quality boots employing the lace-up design for closure.
The Rockport Classic Chukka Boot is fitted with an EVA footbed and a heelcup that conforms to the shape of your feet and provides maximum comfort and support.
Its TPR outsole is also there to ensure that you get the best grip on any kind of surface your walk on.
In terms of comfort and style, this Rockport boot is giving the Allen Edmonds boot a run for its money.
Wolverine 1000 Mile Fashion Boot
This 1000 mile boot is described as America’s original work boot. The Wolverine brand paid meticulous attention to detail when making this boot, and they built it to last very long.
This boot is a great alternative to Allen Edmonds Higgins Mill Boot. Both boots feature a lace-up design for their closure which allows you to get any tightness you want.
The Higgins Mill boot is a rugged boot that comes with a bright saddle leather upper, and a customcork insole that ensures the boot fits your leg perfectly. It has a soft leather lining that makes it really comfortable to wear and gives your foot a great experience.
The Wolverine boot comes with a leather sole that is very durable and ensures a sturdy grip. It also has a round toe design that helps it to accommodate different types of feet.
Similar design, similar features make this boot a perfect alternative to the Allen Edmonds Higgins Mill Boot.
Bruno Marc Urban Suede Oxford Shoes
Bruno Marc really did a good job with this shoe. It is a classic oxford shoe that makes walking to be very comfortable. The high quality and exquisite texture make it one of the most stylish suede shoes out there.
This suede oxford shoe from Bruno Marc serves as an alternative to the Allen Edmonds Strandmok Suede Oxford Shoe.
The Allen Edmond shoe is made from premium rapello suede and has a tan leather lining. Its upper has also been enhanced with a Defender Repellent System.
Meanwhile, the Bruno Marc Oxford shoe is fitted with a leather lining and insole that are moisture absorbent and help to keep your feet fresh and dry. It also comes with a TPR outsole that does not wear out easily and lasts for a very long time.
Both shoes are great and have amazing features, but if you are unable to acquire the Allen Edmonds, the Bruno Marc is also an excellent choice.
Johnston & Murphy Venetian Shoe
If there is any shoe that should make this Allen Edmonds alternative shoes list, it’s this Venetian shoe from Johnston and Murphy. It is a casual shoe that comes with genuine moccasin construction and an EVA sole.
This shoe is an alternative to the Allen Edmonds Venetian Moccasin.
The Allen Edmonds Moccasin was designed in such a way that it repels dirt. It also comes with a rubber sole that provides premium traction.
Meanwhile, the Johnston and Murphy shoe is fitted with a leather lining and removable insole that ensures that the shoe provides you with optimal comfort.
The EVA sole that comes with this shoe has impressive shock absorption that protects your feet from harm.
As you can see, the Johnston and Murphy Venetian shoe provides similar and more benefits than its Allen Edmonds counterpart, and most importantly, for a lower price.
Deer Stags Chelsea Boot
This boot from Deer Stags is the perfect alternative to the Allen Edmonds Chelsea Boot, and by considering both features you will surely understand why.
The Allen Edmonds Chelsea Boot is a great shoe with amazing features like the V-tread tap sole that provides flexibility and superb traction.
It also comes with a customcork insole that ensures that the boot fits perfectly on your leg. The boot is also fitted with a smooth and soft calfskin leather upper that provides comfort and a good feeling to your feet.
Meanwhile, the Deer Stags Chelsea Boot has a smooth synthetic upper instead of leather. It also comes with a soft fabric lining that helps to wick moisture away and keep your feet cool. Its removable memory foam insole and durable rubber outsole ensure that you get the maximum amount of comfort possible.
You can switch your Allen Edmonds with this Deer Stags boot and you still get the same quality.
Clarks Whiddon Cap Oxford Shoe
This is another great alternative to the Allen Edmonds Park Avenue Cap-Toe Oxford shoe. It possesses great features like its Allen Edmonds counterpart and is superior in terms of comfort and style.
The Allen Edmonds Park Avenue Cap-Toe Oxford shoe uses a dainite rubber sole and a customcork insole for fitting. It also comes with a calfskin leather upper.
On the other hand, the Clarks Oxford shoe also uses a leather upper and a lace-up design for its closure. However, it uses a synthetic sole that is soft durable and more flexible.
One of its superior advantages is the removable ortholite footbed that provides superb cushioning and wicks moisture away keeping your feet cool and comfortable.
Temeshu Oxford Shoes
There are many great shoes out there that you can wear in place of Allen Edmonds, and this oxford shoe from Temeshu is one of them.
It is a more affordable and better alternative to the Allen Edmonds McAllister WingTip Shoe.
The Allen Edmonds McAlister shoe is handcrafted and fully lined with leather. It possesses a non-skid rubber heel and a durable leather sole.
The customcork insole fitted in it ensures that the shoe fits your leg like it was customized specially for it.
Meanwhile, the Temeshu Oxford shoe has a rubber sole that is flexible and provides a great cushion to protect your feet and reduce foot fatigue.
This rubber outsole has better elasticity and is also resistant to wear and tear. This shoe comes with breathable linings and lightweight construction that ensures its durability. There are insoles and soft linings in this shoe that help to keep your feet dry and odor-free.
You can confidently replace your Allen Edmonds with this oxford shoe from Temeshu.
Having gone through 20 of the best plan B’s for Allen Edmonds, I believe you found one or two of them worthy to be tried out. A lot of them are way more affordable than Allen Edmonds and they also provide more benefits. Let me know your pick.
Related:
- Shoes Similar to Nike Blazer
- Cushe Shoes Alternatives
- Boots Similar to Alden Indy
- Nike Lunarglide Substitutes
- Boxing Shoes vs Wrestling Shoes
- Converse Alternatives Made In USA
- Shoes Like Vans
This page may contain affiliate links.
To support the content and the knowledge I share here, I earn from qualifying purchases from Amazon at no extra cost to you.