6 Best Insoles for Baseball Cleats (in 2023)

Baseball cleats are a popular product when it comes to sports gear. They are made to be very versatile pieces of equipment that can be worn during a variety of activities.

However, as with any athletic shoe, it may not be made to fit every foot type. Whether you are a professional baseball player or just a casual fan, you are probably aware of the importance of a good pair of baseball cleats.

It is essential to get insoles that ensure your cleats fit well. After all, a poor fit can cause discomfort and even injury while playing the game. I’ll be bringing to you some of the best insoles for your baseball cleats.

Here are my top picks

Best Insoles for Baseball Cleats

  1. Superfeet Comfort shoe Insoles: Most comfortable insole
  2. Superfeet Carbon Shoe Inserts: Best low volume insole
  3. truMedic Athletic Running Insoles: Best insoles that provide relief for various foot illnesses
  4. New Balance Sports High Impact Insole: Best moisture-wicking insoles
  5. Cleat Coolers Insoles: Best heat reducing insoles
  6. Blusol Shoe Inserts: Best one size fits all insoles

Review of my top 6 insoles for baseball cleats

Superfeet Comfort Shoe insoles

Best Insoles for Baseball Cleats

The Superfeet Comfort Premium Insoles are a great choice for those who need to be on their feet all day.

These insoles are made with high-quality foam and include a pillow-top layer that supports the foot and prevents pressure points.

The Superfeet Comfort insoles come in a variety of sizes to ensure that you get the perfect fit.

They also come in a wide range of colors and styles so that you can find something to match your shoes or boots perfectly.

I have been wearing these insoles for about a month now, and I am very pleased with them. The footbed has helped me get rid of some pain in my feet that has been bothering me for years.

The fit is good, but it may take some time to get used to wearing them if you’re not used to wearing insoles already!

These insoles are designed to be worn in any type of shoe, including athletic shoes as well as boots and dress shoes. They fit very well in your baseball cleats

Key features

  • High-quality foam
  • Pillow top layer
  • Variety of sizes


  • Brand: Superfeet
  • Model:  FL143208
  • Weight: 3.84 ounces 


  • Gets rid of pain In the feet
  • Designed for different types of shoes


Has sharp edges of carbon fiber at the bottom which gives a lot of pressure on your heels when standing up

Superfeet Carbon Shoe Inserts

Best Insoles for Baseball Cleats

Superfeet Carbon Shoe Inserts are a great way to improve the comfort and fit of your shoes. They are made from a lightweight carbon fiber material, so they’re strong and durable, but still very flexible.

This makes them ideal for baseballers who want the best of both worlds: durability and flexibility. Plus, they’re designed to support your arches while you walk or run.

I bought them for my brother to play baseball some weeks and he testifies to the fact that they are very flexible, fit well, and are some of the best insoles for your baseball cleats.

Superfeet Carbon Shoe Inserts have a unique design that helps to reduce foot fatigue while you’re on the go.

That’s because they’re made with “ZeoFill” technology which means that they have small air holes throughout the insert that allow your feet to breathe properly while you wear them.

The Superfeet Carbon Shoe Inserts come in five different sizes so that you can choose one that fits perfectly into your shoe size.

Key features

  • Arch support
  • Made with ZeoFill technology
  • Available in various sizes


  • Brand: Superfeet
  • Model: CARBON
  • Weight: 2.08 ounces


  • These insoles are designed to help prevent injury when running or walking by absorbing shock during impact activities.


  • They sometimes don’t last as long as expected

truMedic Athletic Running Insoles

Best Insoles for Baseball Cleats

I recently bought a pair of TruMedic Athletic Running Insoles to replace my old pair of insoles that had worn out.

My first impression was that they were very comfortable and flexible. They fit well in my cleats and provided support and cushioning.

The truMedic Athletic Running Insoles are designed to be used when you are running or walking. They can also be used in other sports such as basketball and football.

The insoles will help improve your posture while exercising and reduce any pain that you may experience in your joints or muscles.

You will notice an increase in energy levels after using these insoles because they help prevent fatigue due to poor circulation by reducing pressure on your lower limbs which causes them to swell up during exercise.

These insoles are also great for people who suffer from plantar fasciitis, overpronation, heel spurs, and other foot illnesses.

They are made with a patented support system that provides the right amount of cushioning and stability for your feet. The insoles are also made with a removable gel pad that can be placed in the arch area for added comfort and support.

Key features

  • Removable gel pad
  • Patented support system


  • Brand: truMedic
  • Model: TM-PWR-SOLE-M
  • Weight: 4.16 ounces


  • They help improve your posture
  • They reduce the pain you may experience in your joints or muscles
  • Great for people who suffer from various foot illnesses

New Balance Sports High Impact Insole

Best Insoles for Baseball Cleats

The New Balance Sports High Impact Insole is an excellent product for those who exercise.

It offers comfort and protection to the feet, ankles, and knees during exercise. It has been designed for running, walking and all other kinds of sports activities.

I have been using these insoles for the past month and I am quite impressed. They are light, flexible, and provide good support.

The gel padding is not too thick or thin so you don’t feel like your feet are being squished. The heel cup is wide enough to hold your ankle in place, but not so wide that it feels like a brace.

This insole is made up of foam that absorbs impact forces during exercise. This foam material also provides cushioning to the feet, ankles, and knees.

It helps reduce stress in those areas which may otherwise be painful when exercising.

The New Balance Sports High Impact Insole also has a heel stabilizer that prevents slippage of the heel during a workout. This heel stabilizer helps prevent injuries such as ankle sprains, shin splints, and knee injuries too.

The New Balance Sports High Impact Insole comes in three different sizes: small, medium, and large.

Key features

  • The foam absorbs impact forces
  • Heel stabilizer
  • Available in various sizes


  • Brand: New balance
  • Model:  FL6388
  • Weight: 4.16 ounces


  • Heel stabilizer which prevents slippage and injuries
  • Made with foam that provides and reduces stress

Cleat Coolers Insoles

Best Insoles for Baseball Cleats

The Cleat Coolers Insoles are one of the best products on the market. They not only look great but they also work great.

These insoles are perfect for any sports shoe or boot, they’re also very easy to install and they come with a 100% satisfaction guarantee.

I really like these insoles because they keep my feet cool during hot days but also because they provide me with extra comfort when running or playing sports.

Made from an ultra-lightweight material, this product ensures a comfortable fit for any kind of shoe.

It has also been designed ergonomically, so it can fit perfectly into your shoes and prevent any discomfort during play or training sessions.

The insoles are flexible, which means that they can be easily put into any pair of shoes without causing any discomfort or pain during play or training sessions.

They are also very lightweight, which makes them easy to carry around when traveling with your gear bag!

The Cleat Coolers Insoles have been designed to help absorb sweat from your feet while at the same time providing them with a cooling effect.

This will keep them cool during hot days or even during intensive exercises such as running or playing soccer on hot days where temperatures can go up to 90 degrees Fahrenheit (32 degrees Celsius).

Key features

  • Made with an ultra-lightweight material
  • Has an ergonomic design
  • Absorbs sweat with a cooling effect


  • Brand: Cleat Coolers
  • Model: CC1
  • Weight: 1.45 ounces


  • Moisture-wicking ability with a cooling effect for added comfort
  • They are flexible and lightweight
  • They keep your fit cool during hot days


  • Not as durable as expected

Blusol Shoe Inserts

Best Insoles for Baseball Cleats

The Blusol shoe inserts have a wide toe box, which is great for my wide feet! This feature makes the shoe inserts very comfortable to wear.

The heel cup has a lot of cushioning and support for my heels. The forefoot also has extra cushioning to protect my toes from rubbing against the front of the shoe.

The Blusol Shoe Inserts are made from high-quality, soft, and breathable material. The shape is curved to fit comfortably in the shoe and the bottom of the insert has a non-slip feature.

The Blusol Shoe Inserts are easy to use and comfortable to wear. They’re very soft and bend easily, allowing you to put them inside any type of shoes without having to worry about them being too tight or uncomfortable.

They’re made from high-quality materials which makes them soft but firm enough not to lose their shape after multiple uses.

They have a non-slip feature on the bottom which helps prevent them from sliding around inside your shoes while you walk around or run around with them on your feet.

Key features

  • Wide toe box
  • Highly cushioned heel cup
  • Extra cushioned forefoot


  • Brand: Blusol
  • Model: B07QRW41GJ
  • Weight: 3.04 ounces


  • Non-slip feature at the bottom which prevents from sliding around in your shoes
  • Has a curved shape to fit comfortably in the shoe


  • Last for only 2 months

Things to consider when choosing insoles for baseball cleats

It’s important to choose the right type of insole for your baseball cleats. It’s not enough to just buy any old pair and call it a day.

You need to know what to look for when choosing insoles for baseball cleats, so you can get the most out of your cleats and your feet.

Here are some things you should consider when choosing insoles for baseball cleats:


The first thing to consider is material. Some materials are more durable than others, which means they will last longer and be less likely to break down over time.

They also tend to be more comfortable, which is important if you plan on wearing them all day long!


The size of your insole will depend on how big or small your feet are, but also on how much room there is inside the shoe itself.

If there’s extra space, you might want a thinner insole that doesn’t take up as much room or one that’s flexible so you can move around more easily while playing baseball or softball.

On the other hand, if there isn’t much extra room inside your shoes, then you might want an insole with more cushioning so it feels more comfortable and helps prevent blisters or other issues.

Get custom-fitted insoles

If you want to get the best possible fit for your feet, then you’ll want to find a local sports medicine and orthopedic specialist who can measure your foot and assess its health.

They will then craft custom-fitted insoles that fit perfectly into your cleats and provide the support your feet need.

Choose foam or gel

Foam is typically more comfortable than gel, but it can compress over time and lose its original shape if not properly cared for by replacing them every so often (usually every few months).

Gel offers more shock absorption than foam, but also tends to compress quicker than foam as well as be hotter than foam because it’s a liquid-like substance rather than solid like foam is.

Consider arch support

Your arches should be supported by the insole in order to properly distribute weight across your foot when walking or running on hard surfaces such as concrete or asphalt.

The right shape

Some models come with different arch heights (the part of your foot’s sole that supports its weight) from zero to maximum support for different types of activity and conditions (such as running).

Others are curved at the back for stability while running downhill; some have bumps on top for better traction; others have more padding underfoot for longer walks.


This page may contain affiliate links.

To support the content and the knowledge I share here, I earn from qualifying purchases from Amazon at no extra cost to you.

Leave a Comment